Comment made at: Bulletman 003 (GM removed)A definite improvement, but I have a couple of comments. (Oh, no!) First, the inside front cover should be strictly greyscale (see Whiz 24). Anything that appears to be color in the original scan was the result of aging paper (and possibly iffy scanner software and early Photoshop), and the original scanner decided to act as if there were spot colors -- which there weren't. I have seen a lot of these. Were they all GM scans? The same is no doubt true of the inside back cover. Second, at the bottom of Page 12, left-hand panel, the guy's jacket has been recolored from blue/white to red. I assume this was intentional to act as a sort of watermark since it doesn't really fix a problem. There WAS a thug in a red jacket (Panels 2 and 3), but he gets taken out in Panel 5, so it's not the same guy. Next, if you're going to go to the trouble to essentially rebuild the comic from the ground up, it would be nice if the paper color were more consistent from page to page. Trying to match them exactly is nearly impossible, but it's possible to get closer than this. Finally, I'm not sure that blurring the halftones (to smooth them) is really a good idea. In most cases it's hardly noticeable. But sometimes with a gradient -- as on Page 23, bottom right -- doesn't work as it should.
Maybe I should try my hand at one of these instead of just criticiz-- er, commenting. I'm open to suggestions.