General Category > Comic Related Discussion

Looking for a comic

<< < (2/2)

Crimson-Blue-Green:
Those fake listings are probably the ones that say "rare" or "exists?".  Such as "The Black Phantom" #2 (ME) or "Nyoka the Jungle Girl" #9 - 13 (Charlton).  Mind you, I only own a well-worn 1986 edition of The Price Guide.  😃

Yoc:
Sorry, I can't recall any more details beyond 'yeah, they slipped some fake books in.'

-Yoc

steveinthecity:
Non-existant books?

Adventures of the Dover Boys (1950)  - #2

All Comics  (Chicago Nite Life; 1945)

Animal Crackers (1946) 1 & 2 do not exist;  (1950s) "nn, nd" -- no such thing, but there is a #9 (1957) published by Green that is not listed.... this is probably what the "nn" line refers to.

A-1 Comics #1 (1944)  does not exist... the nn (Kerry Drake) is actual #1.

Attack  (1953)  OPG accurately lists two #5s, but is a bit confusing... the first is dated Jan '53, and the second is dated  Sep  '53.

Battle Fire  (1955)  #7

Blue Beetle   #43

Camera Comics  (1944)  Two "nn" issues?

Captain and the Kids (1947+)  #1-15

Catholic Comics  (1946)  #1-4

Comedy Carnival (1950s)  This is not a separate comic, but is the same as "All-Picture Comedy Carnival"

Danger is Our Business! (1955)   #4-10

Dime Comics #1  (1951)  There is a 1945 issue.

Dream Book of Romance #124 (#9) (1954)  Does not exist.  This is supposed to be part of the A-1 series, and there is an A-1 #124 -- but it is a humor issue titled "Hot Dog".

Family Funnies #9 (1946) 

Fightin' Marines #11 (Jan '53) There is no "Canteen Kate" by Baker in this issue... OPG has confused this with Approved Comics #11 ("Fightin' Marines") from Aug '54, which does have Canteen Kate.

Hercules  (1968)  OPG lists 2 "low distribution" magazine format issues for this Charlton title, #4 and #8.  The #4 does not exist.

Hot Shot Charlie (1947) 

Jester (1945)  This Chesler title does not exist... it has been confused with Jest.

Johnny Hazard  (1949)  Ran from #5 thru #8.  #35?

Jungle Jim (1949-1951)  #16-20

Katy Keene Fashion Book Magazine  OPG correctly lists that there are no #s 3 thru 10, but misses that there are no issues 11 and 12 either.  The title runs #s 1, 2 and then 13 thru 23.

Keen Detective Funnies (1940)  vol. 3#2

Kid Colt Outlaw  (1950s Album)  OPG lsits this as 132 pages in b&w with cardboard covers.... but it does not seem to exist.  British or Canadian reprint?

Liberty Comics  (1945)  Issue #5

Love Tales #59 (Marvel)

Love Trails #2  (Marvel)

Merry-Go-Round Comics  (1944)  #21

My Secret Life #27 (1950)  Double-entry in OPG... there is no 1950 issue, but the Sep '51 issues does exist.

Private Buck (1941)  There is no Large Feature #22 with Private Buck.

Strange Story #1 (1946)  Although some original art exists, the title was never actually piblished.

Super Duper (Harvey, 1941)  There is a #3 issue from Howard, and there is one or more obscure issues from Britain,  there is a Super-Dooper comic from Harvey, but the #5, #8, and #11 issues listed by OPG here do not exist.

Sweetie Pie  (1955-1957)  There are no issues 3 thru 14.  There are only 3 issues.... 1, 2 and 15.

Sweet Romance #1 (1968)  Charlton.  Does not exist.

United States Marines   #s 7 thru 11 by Toby do not exist.

Varsity (1945)  Another title I can't confirm.... possibly this is a magazine and not a comic book?

Vic Flint   (1949)  #s 3 thru 5 do not appear to exist.

 

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page