So, somebody edited the page at the GCD for Wyatt Earp, Frontier Marshall 21:
http://www.comics.org/issue/171783/and changed the three Maneely stories to Tony Tallarico, commenting that the Maneely credit was "obviously incorrect".
Now, I know the three stories are by Maneely; JVJ identified them when I first posted the book, and they're in the "Maneely at Charlton" collection I did that I know has been seen by other experts on the subject for years without any complaints. However, I am hesitant to go change the page back without some reference I can point to, because I don't want a "person a says/ person b says" scenario. My search fu is weak today, and I can't find the original thread where Jim ID'd the stories. And I don't want to reference my own collection of the Maneely stories; as that's just me quoting myself. So, 3 ways people could help me:
1) Somebody else go edit the page. If it's anybody but myself then referencing the Maneely at Charlton collection is actually using something as a legit source:
http://digitalcomicmuseum.com/index.php?dlid=159132) Somebody with better search fu finds the original posts where JVJ identifies the stories, then I can refer back to that post when editing.
3) Jim (or some other expert) vouches for the three stories in this thread, at which point I can refer back here when editing.
Of course, the alternative is to inform me that I was wrong and deluded when I included the three stories in the collection; and accept the edit at the GCD. I can edit the book instead if that's the consensus.
Thank you in advance for your help.