General Category > Comic Related Discussion

Goodbye, CCA

<< < (2/3) > >>

Roygbiv666:
I'll miss the ubiquitous Comics Code seal.

John C:
I disagree, Bob.  The distributors would've had problems dealing with different approval ratings, then the retailers would've had problems keeping their end together.  We weren't as lawsuit-happy then as we are today, of course, but woe be it to the newsstand owner who dares put the CCA-14 stuff on a rack six inches too low where it's confusable with the CCA-7 material.

The real problem, in my eyes, was in considering the CCA seal a mark of quality rather than one of...essentially a synthetic morality, in that books wouldn't be sold unless they carried the seal.

If you do sell them anyway, then you have your de facto multiple levels (sort of like the "For Mature Readers Only" tag that DC tried for a while), but you also let everybody feel in control.  Readers can choose.  Parents can make demands (like explicit-lyric CDs--people besides me still by CDs, right?).  Towns can require ID checks.  Shop owners can decide between height requirements or tacky "porn-hiding curtains" (or not carrying them at all, sure).

And again, I can't help but think that the situation might be improved just by having someone call an editor to say, "the villain seems rather stereotypically gay.  You might get angry calls."  In-house, you get too much intellectual in-breeding to see when your really clever idea is actually just an offensive inside joke.

(For what it's worth, in today's world where creators actually know the names and faces of many fans, I've wondered if a community-driven content rating might be useful.  But getting information where it needs to be securely in an industry that's terrified of online piracy...might be a difficult aspect.  However, imagine, for example, not only having a "13+" age rating, but having a website where the reviewer can say it's because we're forced to look at Sue Storm in her underwear, Archie fantasizes about decapitating Reggie, or Superman says "crap.")

Yoc:
Interesting idea John.
Reminds me of the old DC 'Editorial Advisory Board' only online with fans instead.

-Yoc

John C:
That may not be surprising:  Considering that DC's internal code became the basis for the Comics Code, it'd make sense if the related censorship board evolved from their advisory board.  After all, as far as I can tell, the presence of the advisory board was the predecessor of the CCA seal:  These guys said we're on the up and up.

Of course, the idea is the easy part.  Getting into a viable state, complimentary (or at least not damaging) to the main business model (of comics, I mean), and then getting acceptance by the companies...well, that's something else entirely.

Yoc:
Yep.
Things sure have changed from the days of the 'Hey Kids, COMICS!' spinner racks in every variety store.
I don't know any kids that even read them these days.  *sigh*

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page